Search for: All records

Abstract The Cretaceous is characterized as a greenhouse climate from elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations, transgressive seas, and temperate ecosystems at polar paleolatitudes. Here we test the hypothesis that the early Cretaceous was a cold climate state with a new Aptian atmospheric carbon dioxide record from the C₃plant proxy and early Cretaceous sea level curve from stable oxygen isotopes of belemnites and benthic foraminifera. Results show that carbon dioxide concentrations were persistently below 840 ppm during the Aptian, validating recent General Circulation Model simulations of ice sheets on Antarctica at those concentrations. In addition, sea level was estimated to be within the ice sheet window for much of the early Cretaceous prior to the Albian. This background state appears to have been episodically interrupted by Large Igneous Province volcanism followed by long-term carbon burial from weathering. We hypothesize that the early Cretaceous was largely an icehouse punctuated by warm snaps. 

Paleo-CO2 reconstructions are integral to understanding the evolution of Earth system processes and their interactions given that atmospheric-CO2 concentrations are intrinsically linked to planetary function. In this talk, we use several case studies, spanning the 3 Phanerozoic Eras, to illustrate the potential of paleo-CO2 records to constrain the magnitude and state-dependency of equilibrium climate sensitivity, to advance our understanding of global biogeochemical cycles, to test the sensitivity of Earth System modeled atmospheric and oceanic circulation to PCO2 over a range of climate states, and to interrogate ecosystem—CO2—climate linkages and physiological responses to CO2. Further advances in these areas, however, are dependent on how well we ‘know’ paleo-CO2 estimates. CO2 estimates exist for much of the past half-billion years, but the degree to which the accuracy and precision of these estimates are constrained is quite variable, leading to substantial uncertainty and inconsistency in paleo-CO2 estimates. Potential sources of this uncertainty and inconsistency include an incomplete understanding of how environmental and ecophysiological conditions and processes imprint the CO2 proxy signals we measure, of the sensitivity of the CO2 estimates to this uncertainty, and differences in approaches to assigning uncertainties to CO2 estimates, among other factors. Application of newly established screening criteria, defined as part of an effort to improve our understanding of how atmospheric CO2 has varied through the Cenozoic, illustrates how the majority of pre-Cenozoic estimates are unreliable in their current form. To address these issues and to advance paleo-CO2 reconstruction, we introduce CO2PIP, a new community-scale project that takes a two-step approach to building the next generation Phanerozoic-CO2 record. Collective efforts are modernizing existing terrestrial-based CO2 estimates through additional analyses, measurements and proxy system modeling to constrain critical parameters used to estimate paleo-CO2. A set of forward proxy system models being developed in collaboration with the CO2 community, will provide a quantified representation of proxy sensitivities to environmental and ecophysiological conditions and processes that govern the CO2 signals. Ultimately, statistical inversion analysis of the simulated and modernized proxy datasets will be used to revise individual CO2 records and to build a new integrated model-data-constrained CO2 record for the Phanerozoic. 

Abstract Drylands occupy nearly 40% of the land surface and comprise a globally significant carbon reservoir. Dryland‐atmosphere carbon exchange may regulate interannual variability in atmospheric CO₂. Quantifying soil respiration rates in these environments is often complicated by the presence of calcium carbonates, which are a common feature of dryland soils. We show with high‐precision O₂measurements in a laboratory potted soil experiment that respiration rates after watering were similar in control and carbonate treatment soils. However, CO₂concentrations were up to 72% lower in the carbonate treatment soil because CO₂was initially consumed during calcite dissolution. Subsequently, CO₂concentrations were over 166% greater in the carbonate treatment soil as respiration slowed and calcite precipitated, releasing CO₂. Elevated δ¹³C values of soil CO₂(>6‰ higher in the treatment than control) confirm that observed differences were due to calcite dissolution. These findings demonstrate that calcite dissolution and precipitation can occur rapidly enough to affect soil gas compositions and that changes in soil CO₂are not always directly related to changes in soil respiration rates. Studies of local soil respiration rates and carbon exchange are likely to be influenced by dissolution and precipitation of calcium carbonates in soils. We estimate that one fifth of global soil respiration occurs in soils that contain some amount of soil carbonate, underscoring the need to account for its obscuring effects when trying to quantify soil respiration and net ecosystem exchange on a regional or global scale. 

The geological record encodes the relationship between climate and atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) over long and short timescales, as well as potential drivers of evolutionary transitions. However, reconstructing CO₂beyond direct measurements requires the use of paleoproxies and herein lies the challenge, as proxies differ in their assumptions, degree of understanding, and even reconstructed values. In this study, we critically evaluated, categorized, and integrated available proxies to create a high-fidelity and transparently constructed atmospheric CO₂record spanning the past 66 million years. This newly constructed record provides clearer evidence for higher Earth system sensitivity in the past and for the role of CO₂thresholds in biological and cryosphere evolution.